Page 1 of 1

Chinese Paladin (1) vs Chinese Paladin 3

Posted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 9:49 am
by Chibi Jennifer
I'm curious to know what you guys think of both TV adaptions!

Which was a better drama, Chinese Paladin or its sequel Chinese Paladin 3?

Vote and share your thoughts!

Re: Chinese Paladin (1) vs Chinese Paladin 3

Posted: Thu Feb 04, 2010 1:04 pm
by Opi
I like CP3
its LESS, notice i said less, of a sad ending
and i think that jing tian is a more playful character than xiao yao was

Re: Chinese Paladin (1) vs Chinese Paladin 3

Posted: Wed Mar 17, 2010 9:36 am
by rubme
I just finished CP3 two days ago. And I can't really decide which one I like better. I like them both. But i think CP3 is growing on me more. So i guess CP3.

Someone should start a thread on the ending of CP3, I think I would have a lot of question that would be needing answers. 8)

And i guess the poll here is broken too.... :shock:

Re: Chinese Paladin (1) vs Chinese Paladin 3

Posted: Tue Sep 21, 2010 1:08 pm
by Chibi Jennifer
I only just finished the series a few days ago..so CP3 is really on my mind..

I reaaaaallllyyy liked Changqing and Zi Xuan..they drove me crazy XD :oops:
As for the overall feel of the story, I liked that CP3 was more serious and had more characters who could fight- something I didn't like about CP1. They also had more actions scenes and the side stories were actually interesting. I even liked the minor-ish character like Mo Mo..

I also really like how Jing Tian was so playful but cared so deeply for his friends.

The main let down IMO is his relationship with Xue Jian.. wasn't as interesting as I had hoped.

Re: Chinese Paladin (1) vs Chinese Paladin 3

Posted: Fri Aug 31, 2012 6:10 pm
by kevinlinus
I was surprised that nobody votes for CP1, I thought Chibi Jennifer would vote for CP1 !
Anyway, CP3 really struck my mind, I would surely rewatch this drama !

In CP1, there were less emotions flowing inside me, not even teary eyes when everybody just died. I think because they dont put much emphasize/ending to make their death more dramatic
In CP3, especially in episode where Mao Mao exchanged his meat for food and Long Kui sacrificed, I was left in tears, it was just saddening

Re: Chinese Paladin (1) vs Chinese Paladin 3

Posted: Sat Sep 01, 2012 10:26 am
by Chibi Jennifer
For me it was actually the opposite. The one thing I liked CP1 over CP3 was that I was really involved with the love story and I cried so many times because it was so emotional. For me, CP3 never quite reached the level. I only cried when Maomao died... no other part of the series touched me as much.

But execution and overall story, CP3 was better imo.

Re: Chinese Paladin (1) vs Chinese Paladin 3

Posted: Sat Sep 01, 2012 5:54 pm
by kevinlinus
Yup, they wrapped the drama nicely :P

Re: Chinese Paladin (1) vs Chinese Paladin 3

Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2013 2:19 am
by xiaoyaoli_lingerli
For me The good points in cp 3 is that the shushan people actually help them defeat evil sword immortal unlike in cp 1 who just did nothing but the opposite

Re: Chinese Paladin (1) vs Chinese Paladin 3

Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2013 2:23 am
by xiaoyaoli_lingerli
Even if no one agrees with me i still liked chinese paladin 1 better even if it has a bad ending for everybody i still love it as a whole . . One thing i notice is the lovestory of both main characters . . . Lixiaoyao and zhao linger moved me the most in cp3 i liked zi xuan and changqing couple better than the xuejian jingtian couple. And yes i admit it i cried the most in cp 1 while cp 3 i somehow just felt sad and dissapointed well in my own opinion

Re: Chinese Paladin (1) vs Chinese Paladin 3

Posted: Sat Aug 10, 2013 2:28 am
by xiaoyaoli_lingerli
And somehow i didnt like the fact that jing tian never knew gong fu till the end and was just given powers by the 8 of them . Well i somehow love huaying and long kui lol

Re: Chinese Paladin (1) vs Chinese Paladin 3

Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 2:44 pm
by Yukinaoni
CP1 drama needs more love :|