Page 1 of 1

Jing Tian vs Li Xiao Yao

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 7:32 pm
by Chibi Jennifer
Which character do you like more, Hu Ge as Li Xiao Yao or Jing Tian?



So let's get a discussion going- whose character is more admirable? Both characters appear to be similar in many many ways yet there are still distinct differences...

Share your thoughts! Who do you like better and why?

Re: Jing Tian vs Li Xiao Yao

Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 8:57 pm
by God
Neither of them. I like Fei Peng and Chong Lou waaaay better.

Re: Jing Tian vs Li Xiao Yao

Posted: Fri Apr 09, 2010 12:05 pm
by rubme
I would say Jing Tian just because he had more tricks. And he was a little bit for violent witch i guess really got my emotions going. Some times i would be mad or sad for him.But in the end it is always just sad. :cry:

Re: Jing Tian vs Li Xiao Yao

Posted: Fri Apr 09, 2010 7:08 pm
by Chibi Jennifer
I think I like Li Xiao Yao better, even though Jing Tian was more clever coming up with ideas.

I thought it was just a tad bit nasty of him to slap both Long Kui and Xue Jian. I know they were both pretty much asking for it (especially Xue Jian who was so annoying at that point and ruining his plan because she didn't trust him)- but he still slapped 2 girls. Hitting girls are is a no-no. 8) He's supposed to be a hero!

But I guess he never really saw himself as a heroic person even though he boasts about it all the time as a joke.

Re: Jing Tian vs Li Xiao Yao

Posted: Fri Jun 11, 2010 2:31 pm
by avfromsd
u cant really decide because they both act the same but i think yi xiao yao matured quicker than jing tian. jing tian was so much better cause he saved the world as yi xiao yao only helped kill a serpent and and the guy controling it.

Re: Jing Tian vs Li Xiao Yao

Posted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 5:21 am
by tangyanzixuan
I like Jing Tian more, but that somewhat has to do with me loving PAL3 more. His story is a bit more interesting.

Re: Jing Tian vs Li Xiao Yao

Posted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 12:26 pm
by xiaoyaoli_lingerli
avfromsd wrote:u cant really decide because they both act the same but i think yi xiao yao matured quicker than jing tian. jing tian was so much better cause he saved the world as yi xiao yao only helped kill a serpent and and the guy controling it.



well Li Xiao Yao still saved the world by defeating bai yue didn't he? hehe

Re: Jing Tian vs Li Xiao Yao

Posted: Mon Apr 04, 2011 3:19 pm
by Chibi Jennifer
I like that Li Xiaoyao was a lot more devoted. You could clearly see how much he cared about Ling'er whereas Jing Tian doesn't seem to show anything for Xue Jian (heck, it takes him half the series to even realise he likes Xue Jian and was clueless Xue Jian felt anything for him)

Xiaoyao also matures and grows as a character as the story progresses wheres Jing Tian is pretty much the same from beginning to end. Jing Tian is very honorable (especially his choice to sacrifice his own life for others) but he has always been like that- he just doesn't show it much since he prefers to show his happy silly side. Xiaoyao's transformation from beginning to end made me feel his character really went through a lot, but was ultimately left with nothing but despair :(

I've recently been rewatching both CP1 ad CP3 and fine Xiaoyao looks better XD I love his hair & outfit more, hehee

Re: Jing Tian vs Li Xiao Yao

Posted: Fri Aug 31, 2012 5:57 pm
by kevinlinus
tangyanzixuan wrote:I like Jing Tian more, but that somewhat has to do with me loving PAL3 more. His story is a bit more interesting.


I agree with you !
I voted for Jing Tian :P , I like his joke more, his romantic moment, how Hu Ge plays him is just perfect :?: